Should You Buy Chobani Greek Yogurt or BJ’s Brand Wellsley Farms Greek yogurt?

wellsley farms greek vanilla yogurt new item

Finding the best deal is a given when it comes to how I shop, but sometimes store brand items don’t live up to their competitor. All of our wallets would love to dish out to the cheaper store brand, but what if your family hates it? Here on the blog, we have started reviewing BJ’s brand products. Check out our reviews before you make a purchase.

Remember BJ’s does have a 100% money back guarantee on all their store brand products. 


Other reviews:


I have been a BJ’s member for almost ten years now and I am very happy. I love that they are offering more store-brand products to help members save money. I enjoy providing you an honest look at how BJ’s brand items stand up to their store brand competition.

Wanna give BJ’s items try for free? Enter our BJ’s gift card giveaways here.

Today I blind taste tested Chobani Greek Vanilla Yogurt to Wellsley Farms Greek Vanilla Yogurt. My kids picked a favorite. You can watch the video below for their reaction and mine or scroll down for the text comparison.

Disclaimer: I am NOT paid to give my opinion. This is NOT a sponsored post. 🙂


Chobani Greek Yogurt

Price: $4.79 for 40 oz. at BJ’s Wholesale

Ingredients: Nonfat Yogurt (Cultured Pasteurized Nonfat Milk, Live and Active Cultures: S. Thermophilus, L. Bulgaricus, L. Acidophilus, Bifidus and L. Casei), Evaporated Cane Juice, Water, Vanilla Extract, Locust Bean Gum, Pectin.

Taste: Smooth, creamy, and light.


Product Features:

  • Only natural ingredients that are not genetically modified (non-GMO)
  • No artificial flavors, sweeteners or preservatives
  • Gluten-free, Kosher-certified and vegan friendly
  • Includes live and active cultures
  • Includes 40 oz. of Greek Yogurt


BJ’s Wellsley Farms Greek Yogurt

Price: $3.99 for 40 oz.

Ingredients: Cultured Pasturized Grade A Non-fat milk, sugar, vanilla flavor, natural flavors, pectin, Lemon Juice Concentrate, Contains Live and Active Cultures: S. Thermophilus, L. Bulgaricus, L. Acidophilus, Bifidus and L. Casei.

Taste: Smooth, Sweet, thicker

Product Features:

  • Nonfat
  • Excellent source of protein
  • Non-GMO
  • Naturally gluten-free
  • Grade A
  • Kosher
  • Good source of calcium
  • Supports small, sustainable agriculture
  • No artificial flavors, colors or preservatives
  • Made in the USA
  • Includes 40 oz. of vanilla Greek yogurt

Check out the FULL LIST of all the BEST Deals at BJ’s Wholesale this week HERE. 


Our Picks:

My Kids ages 4 and 6 picked BJ’s Wellsley Farms Yogurt.  They said it was sweeter.

I picked Chobani because I like the smoother texture and less sweet taste.


We use both of these yogurts in our smoothies, for cheesecakes, and more. The options are endless and the price for both of these yogurts is affordable when you compare to other grocery stores.


BJ’s Club Quick Links:


Which yogurt do you prefer?